Independent Contractor vs Employee

This article provides an overview of worker classification about how to determine if your worker is an independent contractor vs employee.

independent contractor vs employee

It’s important for business owners to understand the proper classification of independent contractor vs employee. How do you know who is an employee or an independent contractor? The answer to this question has important ramifications on business taxes.

Worker classification determines whether or not a business is required to withhold:

  • Income taxes
  • Medicare taxes
  • Unemployment taxes
  • Pay Social Security on earnings paid to people that do work

One of the biggest triggers for an IRS audit is incorrectly classifying employees as independent contractors.


What is an employee?

A person who does work for you such that you control what will be done and how it will be done is considered an employee (under common law).

For example, Jane Smith is a customer service representative for company, Acme, Inc. She works five days a week and is assigned to go to the office Monday through Friday from 9am to 5pm. While she is working she takes calls from customers and answers their questions. Also, she replies to customer service emails that arrive in the customer support inbox. She is paid a commission on any products or services she up-sells to existing customers. Acme, Inc. pays her health insurance. All of this makes Jane an employee of Acme, Inc.

What is an independent contractor?

An individual is considered an independent contractor if they’re in control of how the work is done and what is done to deliver the work. What this means is the independent contractor determines what hours of the day they work, and what days of the week they work. In addition, independent contractors aren’t required to come to an office. Independent contractors come to the office when they want. The only control the employer has in this situation is the result of the work. Further, the earnings of an independent contractor are subject to Self-Employment tax.

Common job types where people are hired as independent contractors are, dentists, veterinarians, lawyers, accountants, contractors, subcontractors, etc. Essentially, anyone who offers their services to the general public.

Still not sure; how to decide an employee vs non employee?

There are three categories of control to help you determine in your payee is an employee vs non employee.

Behavioral Control

A worker is an employee when a business has the right to direct and control the workers work. This is known as behavioral control. Different categories of behavioral control are described below to clarify if a worker is an employee vs non employee.

  • Type of instruction given. For example, the company specifies when and where to work. What tools to use or where to purchase supplies and services.
  • Degree of instruction. More detailed instruction is indicative the worker is an employee. Whereas less instruction means less control and likely that the worker is an independent contractor.
  • Evaluation systems. An evaluation system about ‘how’ the work is done indicates that the worker is an employee. However, an evaluation systems that measure the end result of the work could mean the worker is either an employee or an independent contractor.
  • Worker training. When you train a worker about how to do a job this worker is likely and employee. Further, periodic or on-going worker training about procedures and methods means that the worker is an employee. Independent contractors are free to use their own procedures and methods in the course of doing their work.

Financial Control

Financial control has to do with the rights the business has in regards to the financial aspects of the worker’s job. The following things need to be considered:

  • Investment in equipment. If a significant investment is made in equipment used by the worker to do a job for someone else.
  • Expense reimbursement. Typically, employees are reimbursed for expenses and independent contractors are not.
  • Profit of loss opportunity. Opportunity for profit or loss indicates that the work is an independent contractor.
  • Services available to the market. Independent contractors are free to work for more than one payor at a time.
  • Method of payment. Employees are typically on the payroll and paid a regular wage. Employees receive wages in regular paychecks biweekly, monthly or any other period of time. Sometimes they’re paid by the hour. In contrast, independent contractors are often paid a flat rate for a job.

Relationship

The type of relationship between a company and a worker often depends on how the worker and the business perceive their interaction with one another. This includes the following:

  • Contracts. Written contracts that describe the relationship intended to create between the business and the worker. However, please note that a contract stating specifically that the worker is an employee or an independent contractor is not enough to establish the workers status. The other topics in this article need to be taken into consideration.
  • Benefits. A worker provided benefits, such as health insurance, 401K, paid vacation day, paid sick days, etc., are employees. Independent contractors typically don’t get these benefits.
  • Relationship duration expectation. A worker is typically classified as an employee if the working relationship is expected to continue indefinitely. On the other hand, the worker is classified as an independent contractor if the relationship is for a specific project or for only a specified amount of time.
  • Services provided are key activity of the business. Typically and employee performs services that are regarded as key aspects of the business that employs them.

Read the following article for more details about the different type of employee benefits, when if provided make the worker classified as an employee: Employee Benefits that Mean Your Worker is an Employee.

What are the consequences of misclassifying an employee?

A business that incorrectly classifies an employee as an independent contractor is liable for employment taxes. Employers can use Form SS-8, Determination of Worker Status for Purposes of Federal Employment Taxes and Income Tax Withholding, to help them determine the status of their workers.

Additional IRS Resources

About Falcon Expenses

Falcon Expenses is an iOS solution for expense tracking and management. Scan receipts, we type merchant, date and amount, auto-track mileage expenses via GPS and log billable hours with an integrated timer. Quickly organize expenses by time period, project or client and easily prepare reports for email to anyone in PDF or spreadsheet formats, all from your phone. Use for reimbursements, taxes, record keeping or invoicing. Falcon Expenses is great for professionals, freelancers, realtors, business travelers, truckers and more. Find out more, here.

Please check out the following articles for more information about Falcon Expenses features and services:

You may also like...